Tina Fey

Portia Nathan

Paul Rudd

John Pressman

Michael Sheen

Mark

Lily Tomlin

Susannah

Gloria Reuben

Corinne

Wallace Shawn

Clarence

Travaris Spears

Nelson

Christopher Evan Welch

Brandt

Sonya Walger

Helen

Dan Levy

James

Sarita Choudhury

Rachel

Rob Campbell

Richard

Olek Krupa

Polokov

Brian d'Arcy James

Christopher Flynn

Leigha Hancock

Yulia Karasov

Elaine Kussack

Abby

Lisa Emery

Mrs. Pressman

Nat Wolff

Jeremiah

Ann Harada

Mrs. Lafont

Ben Levin

Junior Lafont

Michael Genadry

Ben

Zachary Unger

Jeremiah - 8 Years Old

Lynne Taylor

Jeremiah's Mom

Mihran Slougian

Jeremiah's Dad

Maggie Keenan-Bolger

Girl on Tour

Juliet Brett

Praying Applicant

John Brodsky

Smug Kid

Camille Branton

Gymnast

Nadia Alexander

Quest Student

Laura Jordan

Woman

Jarod Einsohn

Keg Guy

Sarah Quinn

Young Mother

Tina Benko

Andrea (uncredited)

Giullian Yao Gioiello

Princeton Applicant (uncredited)