Fred MacMurray

Bill Morgan

Joan Leslie

Sally Smith / Prudence / Katrina

June Haver

Lucilla Powell / Gretchen / Indian

Gene Sheldon

Ali the Genie

Anthony Quinn

Chief Badger

Carlos Ramírez

Benito

Alan Mowbray

General George Washington

Fortunio Bonanova

Christopher Columbus

Herman Bing

Hessian Col. / Von Heisel

Howard Freeman

Kreiger

Rory Calhoun

Soldier Leaving Canteen (uncredited)

Otto Preminger

General Rahl (uncredited)