Cast (31)
Justin McElroySelf / Chris Evergreen
Travis McElroySelf
Griffin McElroySelf
Sydnee McElroySelf / Tabitha Bigcity
Teylor SmirlSelf / Tabitha's Friend
Rachel McelroySelfTommy SmirlSelf / Tabitha's DadTeresa McelroySelfRileigh SmirlSelf / Tabitha's Friend
Barbara DunkelmanSelf
Clint McElroySanta ClauseCarol McElroyProfessor Clause
Matt ChapmanStrong Bad (Voice) / Homestar Runner (Voice)
Rob CorddrySelf
Lin-Manuel MirandaSelfLaser Malena-WebberSelfAubrey TurnerSelf
Erika IshiiSelfAmanda ColemanSelf
Mara WilsonSelf
Felicia DaySelfCharlie McElroySelfBebe McElroySelfHenry McElroySelf
Ron FunchesSelf
Jeremiah WatkinsSelf
Ben SchwartzSelfMary SmirlChris' Mom
Melissa FumeroSelf
Krystina ArielleSelfDwight SlappeJesus Impersonator