Tom Everett Scott

Nick Pearson

Tituss Burgess

The Amazing Fabular

Julian Feder

Mason

Rachel Boston

Sydney Bartlett

Rhea Seehorn

Kelly

Julie Ann Emery

Joanna

Arden Myrin

Janice Bodicker

Maria de Lourdes Severny

Carla Intinoli

Emily De Margheriti

Daisy

Joyce Bulifant

Betty Bartlett

Chris Levine

Winifred 'Winny'/Freddy

Bryan Batt

Reverend McGooley

Ray Abruzzo

Walter

Beth Riesgraf

Schyler Cross

Andrew Bowen

Richard

Michael McHale

Deejay

John Landis

Psychic #4

Marisa Tomei

Christine Hurley

Joyce Bulifant

Betty Bartlett

Kimberly Blair

Psychic #2

Roger Perry

Phil Bartlett

Nathan Arenas

Frankie

Lewie Bartone

Chaz

Johnny Visotcky

Jimmy

Bo Foxworth

Dad

Patrice Barrie

Old Annie

Jeris Poindexter

Attendant

Rico E. Anderson

CHP Officer

Daisy Traina

Karate Girl

David Loden

Delivery Room Doctor

Tiffany Yvonne Cox

Delivery Room Nurse #1

Mary Hollis Inboden

Delivery Room Nurse #2

Todd Traina

Psychic #1

Rachel McHale

Psychic #3

Olivia Levine

Psychic #5

Ben Begley

Security Guard