Victor Garber

Jesus

David Haskell

John / Judas

Katie Hanley

Katie

Merrell Jackson

Merrell

Joanne Jonas

Joanne

Robin Lamont

Robin

Gilmer McCormick

Gilmer

Jeffrey Mylett

Jeffrey

Jerry Sroka

Jerry

Lynne Thigpen

Lynne

John-Michael Tebelak

Pharisee Monster (voice)