Catherine O'Hara

Sheena

Joe Pantoliano

Jake Maclean

Sarah Polley

Connie

Stephen Rea

Brian

Alison Pill

Jessica

David Hewlett

Nick

Bernard Behrens

Monsieur Farrin

Fab Filippo

Michael

Joel S. Keller

Kevin

Emily Hampshire

Margaret

Leslie Hope

Alice

Joel Keller

Kevin

Dan Lett

Sam

Carl Marotte

Stan

Callum Keith Rennie

Martin Maclean

Albert Schultz

Sheena's Date

Jacob Tierney

Justin

Alberta Watson

Nita

Martha Burns

Gwen Maclean

Nina Shock

Phoebe

Kirsten Kieferle

Sylvia

Semi Chellas

Miriam

Amanda Ciccoritti

Katie

Alix Bemrose

Ballet Dancer

Alex Appel

Gothic Mom

Joshua Tucci

Jake's Son

Katie Boland

Jake's Daughter

Gerry Quigley

Pest Dispatcher

Karyn Dwyer

Teenage Girl

Justin Peroff

Teenage Boy

Mary Long

Mrs. Fagnano

Louis Di Bianco

Mr. Fagnano

Anna Starnino

Aunt Dana

Carmela Albero

Nonna

Frank Crudele

Uncle Aldo

Ingrid Veninger

Stage Manager

Michael Polley

Theatre Director

Noel S Baker

Writer

Jennifer Parsons

Bank Teller 1

Marcia Johnson

Bank Teller 2

Mark Dailey

TV Reporter

Morgan Freeman

Paper Boy

Jennifer Dale

Laura Lorrie (uncredited)