Cast (58)
Joshua ZemanHimselfBarbara BrancaccioHerselfBill EllisHimself - Professor of Folklore, Penn StateDorothy D'ElettoHerself - Archivist & Researcher
Geraldo RiveraHimself - Reporter (archive footage)Karen SchweigerHerself - Jennifer Schweiger's MotherDavid NavarroHimself - Former NewscasterDonna CutugnoHerself - Founder, Friends of JenniferRalph AquinoHimself - Retired Detective, NYPDBobby JensenHimself - Retired Detective, NYPDErnie AnastosHimself - Reporter (archive footage)Andre RandHimself - SuspectJim CallaghanHimself - Former Editor, Staten Island EagleJim DolanHimself - Reporter (archive footage)Theresa DoyleHerself - Searcher for JenniferEd ArmstrongHimself - Holly Ann Hughes's BrotherSean HughesHimself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage)Peter HughesHimself - Holly Ann Hughes's FatherHolly CederholmHerself - Holly Ann Hughes's MotherKen SchweigerHimself - Jennifer Schweiger's FatherJohn O'BrienHimself - Reporter, Staten Island AdvanceDuane FeltonHimself - Defense Attorney for Andre RandLarry SimonHimself - Defense Attorney for Andre RandWilliam L. MurphyHimself - Staten Island District AttorneyTrina CutugnoHerself - Donna's DaughterDevin CutugnoHimself - Donna's SonJimmy RassiasHimself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond DeliKristine GoslingHerself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPDLuis RiveraHimself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPDFrank SaezHimself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPDJack WhitfordHimself - Stapleton Civilian Observation PatrolThomas JenkinsHimself - Staten Island ResidentBob GrahamHimself - Acquaintance of RandFrances AuritiHerself - Searcher, Friend of JenniferTracy BegleyHerself - Searcher, Friend of JenniferGlenn ChapmanHimself - Former Reporter, Staten Island AdvanceLeonard D'AlessandroHimself - Retired Detective, NYPDMartha HintonHerself - WitnessFrank MarchionneHimself - Retired Detective, NYPDTanya GoodsonHerself - WitnessRita DimartinoHerself - Aunt of Alice PereiraCharles G. Muskett Sr.Himself - Former MinisterSteve BogenHimselfPatricia CaridadHerselfRobert CarusoHimselfGreg CusickHimselfCharlie CutugnoHimselfDaniel M. Donovan Jr.Himself - District Attorney for Richmond CountyMarla DziergowskiHerselfRobert FosterHimselfMelissa GraceHerselfJudah LazarusHimselfBruce MeyersenHimselfThomas MicolHimself - Staten Island ResidentCarolyn MuskettHerselfMarie PiazzaHerselfLorraine ShanleyHerselfBrett StraniereHimselfCrew
Directing
Production
- Barbara BrancaccioProducer
- Jeffrey Kusama-HinteExecutive Producer
- Zachary MortensenExecutive Producer
- Maria Elena Lopez-FrankAssociate Producer
- Evan KraussCo-Executive Producer
- Corbin DayAssociate Producer
- Jonathan GrayCo-Executive Producer
- Todd TiberiAssociate Producer
- Jeffrey Kusama-HinteExecutive Producer
- Joshua ZemanProducer