Vincent Price

Charles Dexter Ward / Joseph Curwen

Debra Paget

Ann Ward

Lon Chaney Jr.

Simon Orne

Frank Maxwell

Dr. Marinus Willet / Priam Willet

Leo Gordon

Edgar Weeden / Ezra Weeden

Elisha Cook Jr.

Gideon Smith / Micah Smith

John Dierkes

Benjamin West / Jacob West

Milton Parsons

Jabez Hutchinson

Cathie Merchant

Hester Tillinghast

Guy Wilkerson

Gideon Leach / Mr. Leach

Barboura Morris

Mrs. Weeden

I. Stanford Jolley

Carmody, Coachman

Harry Ellerbe

Minister

Darlene Lucht

Miss Fitch

Bruno VeSota

Bruno, the Bartender

Don Ames

Villager (uncredited)

Jack Tornek

Lynch Mob Member (uncredited)

Nina Borget

Villager (uncredited)

Albert Cavens

Villager (uncredited)

Charles Fogel

Villager (uncredited)