Laura Linney

Sherry Johnson

Peter Fonda

Doctor Cantway

Steve Buscemi

Doc O'Connor

Jeremy Davies

Jedadiah Schultz

Nestor Carbonell

Moisés Kaufman

Kathleen Chalfant

Anonymous Female Rancher

Camryn Manheim

Rebecca Hilliker

Clea DuVall

Amanda Gronich

Michael Emerson

Reverend

Christina Ricci

Romaine Patterson

Margo Martindale

Trish Steger

Janeane Garofalo

Catherine Connolly

Joshua Jackson

Matt Galloway

Mark Webber

Aaron McKinney

Ben Foster

Aaron Kreifels

Lois Smith

Lucy Thompson

Amy Madigan

Reggie Fluty

Clancy Brown

Rob Debree

Dylan Baker

Rulon Stacey

Bill Irwin

Harry Woods

Terry Kinney

Dennis Shepard

Summer Phoenix

Jen Malmskog

Noah Fleiss

Shannon Shingleton

Grant Varjas

Greg Pierotti

Andy Paris

Stephen Belber

Kelli Simpkins

Leigh Fondakowski

Frances Sternhagen

Marge Murray

Regina Krueger

Alison Mears

Greg Pierotti

Jon Peacock

John McAdams

Jonas Slonaker

Michael K. Osborn

Murdock Cooper

Anne Cloud

Kristin Price

Garrett Neergaard

Russell Henderson

Steef Sealy

Bill McKinney

Leslie Henson

Catherine Connolly's Partner

Tom Bower

Father Roger Schmit

James Murtaugh

Reverend Fred Phelps

Daniel Ahearn

Arraignment Judge

Richard Riehle

Henderson Trial Judge

Amanda Gronich

Zackie Salmon

Mercedes Herrero

Pam Sears

Billie McBride

Waitress

Bill Christ

Man on the Porch

Stephen Belber

Anonymous Friend of Aaron McKinney

Barbara Pitts

Sherry Aanenson